Restaurants in passing: The Flo-Jean, Port Jervis NY

updated 31 August 2019
"Pub. by Planned Color Advertising Inc., Stroudsburg PA
Made by Dexter, West Nyack NY"
(from inscription on back of card)
Permanence. As a child, I thought everything that was had always been and would always be. It takes a few years to realize that change is life's certificate of authenticity. The bustling railroad towns of Port Jervis and Middletown NY I knew in the 1950s are now just memories, personal experiences shared with fewer and fewer of my contemporaries.

Sometimes as a consequence of community decline and occasionally due to changes in customer preference or competition, staid old landmark restaurants pass into history. Featured here are a few I have known and some I wish I had known. All have passed into history.

The Flo-Jean, Port Jervis NY

Google Earth spots the long, rambling Flo-Jean restaurant building between the Delaware River
and Water Street. Throughout its history, the Flo-Jean was both blessed and threatened by its riverside location. This restaurant had an excellent reputation for quality service and good food. In my mind, it never fully took advantage of the river views. On occasion, however, the Delaware became a bit too personal, depositing fresh fish and other aquatic life inside the building.
Flo-Jean "Party Room, serving Dinners, Weddings and Banquets for all occasions." (source: post card published by Valence Color Publishers, Canadensis PA. Genuine Natural Color made by Dexter Press, Inc., West Nyack NY.")  I don't remember which of the dining rooms my family ate in, but we always thought of the Flo-Jean as a special family place and favorite destination.  Note the green ash trays from the era when smoke-filled dining rooms were the rule. Outside of gas stations and library stacks, nobody had ever heard of non-smoking areas! 
The Flo-Jean incorporated in its complex the toll house for the once-busy
bridge across the Delaware. The Flo-Jean's "Toll House Bar" displayed
this original sign "to remind many of our older guests of stories of Toll
paying days." (source: postcard by Jo[h]n Valence, Stroudsburg PA)
Here's a look at some of the conveyances listed on the Toll sign:

4 wheeled pleasure carriage as seen on eBay listing 272270688242 Mikeamie07
Stage wagon ride (YouTube ~3 min.)

Chaise, from the
Archives of Pearson Scott Foresman, donated to the Wikimedia Foundation
"Once busy" describes the Port Jervis area very well. It was a canal town, then a railroad town and is now bypassed by intercity traffic altogether. At a time when all traffic passed over the Delaware at Port Jervis, the Flo-Jean prospered. Its prosperity continued through various owners during the time when the Erie Railroad's freight traffic was sorted out in the nearby yards.

As detailed in the remarks below by Thom Marion* [see note at bottom of post], the importance of Port Jervis as a transportation center declined. (Thom corrects my incorrect notion that the Lackawanna was favored over the Erie when the railroads merged.) Interstate traffic that used to pass through town past the Flo-Jean took the new Route 84 bridge over the Delaware. In the 1960s, I boarded one of the last passenger trains from Binghamton through Port Jervis to my home in Middletown NY. 

Water Street, at the Flo-Jean's front door, shows the effects of this transportation shift. Vacant storefronts and detiorating facades are too common. Many buildings have been torn down, including most associated with the Erie Railroad operations. The contemporary picture is brightened by the rehabilitation of the Erie Depot, but the Flo-Jean's demolition was unavoidable. Operating a restaurant that nobody passes by anymore in a decaying, ramshackle complex of haphazardly connected individual buildings occasionally invaded by flood waters is too much of a challenge.

(Google Street View)
"Toll House
This building, a toll house
for the bridge spanning the
Delaware from 1871-1922,
was incorporated into the
Flo-Jean restaurant in 1929."
From the Mid-Delaware bridge, this Street View shows the Delaware side of the rambling Flo-Jean complex, consisting of many "incorporations." The old toll house building is on the right.
Tolls were collected by the Barrett Bridge Company until 1922.
Demolition is never a happy occasion, especially for historic landmarks. Here is a clip of the demolition of the Flo-Jean:

The restored (1986) Erie Depot. Trains passed by to your left. From the historical marker:
"Built in 1892, enlarged in
1912, this building served
as the Delaware Division's
largest station until its
closing in the mid-1970s."
The Erie Hotel still welcomes patrons next door to the restored Erie Depot.
the new depot
Port Jervis is the northern terminus of Metro-North, which operates commuter service between there and New York City on the southern portion of the old Erie line. It's a long commute, but the Port Jervis area has many attractions as a bedroom community. 
Google Earth's Port Jervis with areas of interest highlighted.
[click to enlarge]
The Flo-Jean Restaurant is located at the top center of the Google Earth image above at the intersection of Pike and Water, with the old Erie station at lower left, the new Metro North station lower center and the former Erie roundhouse floor with turntable lower right.

A few blocks east of the Flo-Jean, Pike Street tunnels under the remaining two of what used to be a dozen or so tracks of the old Erie Railroad on its way to the bridge over the Delaware where the Flo-Jean location at the Water Street intersection used to be prime commercial territory.

Below are aspects of the Pike Street Tunnel as captured by Google Street View, and the skeleton of a similar underpass for Sleepy Hollow Road further north along the old Erie line.

Sturdy architecture, meant to last for ages. Towers of lights illuminated the Erie freight yards as
watchmen kept a careful eye on activities. While the freight yard bustled above, traffic was heavy
on Pike Street as intercity travelers headed for the Delaware bridge on America's famous
east-west artery, Route 6. (Google Street View, Oct 2015)
Interstate 84 made short work of traffic on Route 6 while rail traffic withered as the federal
government built public rights of way for auto & truck traffic. Compared to the thousands of
miles of private rights of way maintained by rail companies, which paid taxes on them, their
competition, trucking companies using free interstate highways, had an advantage.
(Google Street View modified in Picasa)
Today, the Pike Street freight yard underpass is as a deserted as a Roman ruin. As you can see in the picture above, it's been years since even graffiti artists paid any attention to the walls!

Pike Street Tunnel (Street View)
Sleepy Hollow Road underpass
Remnants of Erie days are imprinted all over Port Jervis. In the late 1950s, when my grandfather Diver's employer, the New York Ontario and Western railroad collapsed, leaving Middletown NY without one of its major employers, I used to envy Port Jervis residents, who still had a working railroad. I would never have imagined Port Jervis would suffer the same fate, but it's all part of the same process, national infrastructure collapse.

The footprint of the old Erie roundhouse is clearly outlined in this Google Earth photo.
As I understand it, the turntable still works.
No. 833 at rest on the Erie turntable - October, 2015.
Power for the New York & Greenwood Lake Railway is rusting comfortably within the
footprint of the old Erie Roundhouse. By the way, the Minisink Valley Historical Society
has great information on regional railroads.

4/27/2013: Metro North Port Jervis Line; #75 @ Port Jervis Station; Port Jervis, NY by Philip M. Goldstein (YouTube: ~3min.)

Port Jervis, Still a Railroad Town by dumbbuff
(YouTube: ~7min.)

On the occasion of the Flo-Jean's demolition in October, 2015 the Times-Herald Record published a summary of the restaurant's history and a series of pictures by Jessica Cohen in which it was noted the present owner, Lynn Wallace Gallo,
"...did save the Toll House sign displaying toll rates, guest books with comments going back to the 1930s, plus boxes of photos and news articles. She donated much to the Minisink [Valley] Historical Society, which will have an exhibit of Flo-Jean’s memorabilia...."
The Pocono Record also published an article with photos of the demolition, noting the restaurant's origins as follows:
"Inspired by a fishing trip with novelist Zane Grey, General Motors executive Harold Dalrymple built Flo-Jean's El Patio Tea Shop in 1929, named for his wife, Florence, and her sister Jean."
Here's a YouTube flyover of the 
Port Jervis area by John Donnery.
It is a beautiful view of the landscape
that ties together much of what has been
posted above. Thanks, John!

*Due to the demise of Google+, the remarks by Thom Marion were lost. From my email files, I have made a partial recovery as follows:

"I knew the Erie-Lackawanna in and around Port Jervis, fairly well during the years leading up to the formation of Conrail, in 1976. Because of that, I must take issue with the writer of the article linked here. After the merger of the Erie and Lackawanna railroads, the Erie side, through Port Jervis remained the primary route for the new company. It wouldn't be downgraded to secondary status until Conrail.

"Port Jervis Yard remained viable up until the ex-New Haven, Penn Central bridge at Poughkeepsie...[suffered a disabling fire and was abandoned]." - Thom Marion

Much political and corporate shenanigans characterized the demise of the railroad over what is now the Walkway Over the Hudson State Historic Park at Poughkeepsie:

"All traffic was rerouted over other lines and crossed the Hudson on the Penn-Central. Castleton Bridge below Albany. The Lehigh & Hudson River and the Erie-Lackawanna entered legal complaints about loss of valuable interchange traffic and this loss helped drive both of them into bankruptcy shortly thereafter. When Penn-Central went bankrupt, all the various lines were lumped together into the new unified Consolidated Rail Corporation, better known as Conrail. As a monopolistic carrier Conrail has shown no interest in reopening the Poughkeepsie Bridge Route and prefers to pass on the additional cost of operating via the Castleton Detour to New England shippers and receivers in the form of large surcharges. In 1982 it remains out of service. Shippers in New England and mine owners in Pennsylvania have exerted political pressure to get it reopened and Congress passed legislation in 1978 mandating its repair, modernization, and reopening and authorizing $9,000,000 to do so. Conrail countered with new wildly inflated repair estimates and false references to "iron construction" and "rotting wooden pilings," when in fact engineering studies confirm the basically good condition of its Bessemer Steel structure and all-masonry piers." - Arthur G. Adams

The author of this blog has attempted to correctly apply terms and conditions to Content. These pages and associated images are being made available exclusively for use in non-commercial and non-profit study, scholarship, research, or teaching . Researchers are responsible for using these materials in accordance with Title 17 of the United States Code and any other applicable statutes. All trademarks, service marks, trade names, trade dress, product names and logos appearing on this blog are the property of their respective owners.. In the event that any Content infringes your rights or Content is not properly identified or acknowledged please email me. Thanks! 

Comments

  1. Summers, on the way from Passaic, NJ to Milford, PA, our uncle and aunt would religiously stop at Flo-Jean's to treat my older brother and I to a lunch. I recall looking from the dining room window to across the river and Matamoras. My impression of the distance across the water was far wider than it is. Funny how a place can sink into a child and remain so poignant a part of his life.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. A special place for special people! It seemed to me we were dining right on the surface of the river, and when in flood, the Flo-Jean was.

      Delete
    2. Absolutely remember the Flo-Jean. My Mother took my Aunt & I there one year for Thanksgiving dinner rather than cook herself, for just the three of us. The place was amazingly decorated with antique dolls & carriages. The tables were set with mismatched vintage restaurant-ware, and it all made for a happy & friendly environment I will not ever forget that afternoon.
      Especially the view of the bridge & river below. Sad to see it is now gone. All but the memories.

      Delete

Post a Comment

Comments will not appear immediately. They are sent to the blog author for "moderation." If they are relevant to the content, it is more than likely they will appear. Suggestions welcome!